Organic Peanut Butter Alternatives

Make breakfast, lunch, and snacks more interesting with fresh and healthy peanut butter alternatives from Naturally Nutty.

Our handcrafted nut and seed butters are made from the very best ingredients in small batches for the superior taste and quality our customers enjoy.

When you want to savor a pure, healthy alternative to the major brands, you can count on Naturally Nutty for tasty spreads in a variety of delicious gourmet flavors. All of the spreads are made in small batches to ensure the highest quality and safety.

Our peanut butter alternatives will brighten your morning breakfast toast and rejuvenate lunches, snacks, and even baking. Here are just a few of our most popular vegan spreads, each packed with carefully-sourced natural and organic ingredients:

Sugar Free Organic Pepita Sun Oatmeal Butter – This newest edition to our selection of artisan nut and seed butters is great for anyone who shuns sugar but doesn’t want to sacrifice flavor. We’ve blended organic pepita (pumpkin) seeds, sunflower seeds, flax, hemp, and chia with gluten-free organic oats and a little spice. This delicious butter will not only make you want seconds, but it offers the benefits of rich ingredients hand-picked for their iron, magnesium, plant protein, and mood-boosting nutrients. We can’t think of a better energy boost any time of the day.

Organic Chocolate Sunflower Butter – It’s true: there is a chocolate taste that is really healthy and packed full of vitamins. Indulge your love of chocolate any time of day with a popular, decadent twist that dresses up our plain sunflower butter. We have blended rich organic cocoa powder with pure sunflower, flax, hemp seeds, and other organic ingredients for a power-packed spread as delectable as it is satisfying.

Organic Cinnamon Vanilla Almond Butter – What do you get when you combine the superior taste of fresh organic almonds from California with the finest organic cinnamon and vanilla and a blend of chia, hemp, and flax seeds? Unforgettable smooth flavor and a protein punch with the added benefits of fiber and antioxidants. You might appreciate that it’s healthy, but you will really love the taste.

Organic Mocha Almond Butter – Can’t enjoy the day without a cup of fair trade organic coffee? We’ve taken the smooth, rich taste of fair trade coffee and mixed it with organic cocoa power, fresh Californian almonds, plus chia, hemp, and flax seeds for one of our most popular, delicious, and healthy peanut butter alternatives.

These are just a few of our growing selection of fine artisan nut and seed butters. Plus, we are pleased to offer products with options for those with food allergies and sensitivities. You’ll notice that we always indicate if a nut or seed butter is gluten free, dairy-free, soy-free, and nut-free; and you can rest assured that allergen separation is something we take very seriously.